Understanding NCAV: The Key to Deep Value

Benjamin Graham's 'cigar-butt' strategy offers a powerful, if unconventional, path to market-beating returns.

In a market obsessed with growth, narratives, and the next disruptive technology, the quiet, methodical art of deep value investing can seem like a relic from a bygone era. Yet, for the discerning investor, it holds a powerful secret weapon—a formula so stringent and conservative that it has guided practitioners to remarkable returns for nearly a century. This tool is the Net Current Asset Value, or NCAV.

Pioneered by Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing and mentor to Warren Buffett, NCAV is the ultimate test of a bargain. It's a method for finding companies trading for less than the value of their spare parts—what Graham famously called "cigar-butt" investing: finding a discarded cigar with one good puff left in it. The puff is free, and that's where the profit lies.

---

What Exactly is Net Current Asset Value?

The NCAV calculation is deceptively simple. It strips a company down to its most liquid components, offering a rock-bottom estimate of its liquidation value. The formula is:

Let's break this down:

• Current Assets are assets expected to be converted into cash within one year—cash itself, accounts receivable (money owed by customers), and inventory.
• Total Liabilities encompass everything the company owes, both short-term and long-term.

The most telling part of this formula is what it excludes: all long-term assets. Property, plants, equipment, patents, and goodwill are all assigned a value of zero. Graham's logic was ruthless but brilliant: in a forced liquidation scenario, the true market value of these illiquid assets is uncertain. By ignoring them completely, the NCAV provides an immense margin of safety.

---

The Investment Thesis: Buying a Dollar for 50 Cents

The magic happens when you compare a company's NCAV to its market capitalization (the total value of all its shares). To do this on a per-share basis, the calculation is:

An investment opportunity arises when a company's stock price trades for less than its NCAV Per Share.

Imagine finding a company with an NCAV per share of $10 that is currently trading on the stock market for $7. In theory, you are buying $10 worth of easily saleable assets for just $7. If the company were to close its doors, pay off all its debts, and sell its remaining current assets, shareholders would receive $10 for every share they owned—a handsome 43% profit.

Graham went even further, advising investors to only buy stocks trading at a significant discount to their NCAV, typically at two-thirds of the value or less. Buying that $10 NCAV for $6.67 or less provided an even greater margin of safety.

---

Why Does This Opportunity Even Exist?

In an efficient market, how could a company possibly trade for less than its net cash and inventory? The answer usually lies in pessimism and neglect.

NCAV stocks are almost never glamorous. They are often small, obscure companies in unpopular industries that have been posting losses or facing significant headwinds. The market has written them off, believing their current assets will be eroded by future losses.

The deep value investor, however, is not betting on a miraculous turnaround. They are betting that the market's pessimism is excessive and that the underlying asset value provides a floor for the stock price. The catalyst for profit could be anything from a return to slight profitability, a takeover offer, or even an activist investor forcing liquidation.

---

The Risks and Realities of the Cigar-Butt Approach

While powerful, NCAV investing is not without its pitfalls:

Value Traps

The primary risk is that the company is a "value trap." If management is inept or fraudulent, it can continue to burn through the company's current assets, eroding the NCAV month after month until the margin of safety disappears.

Patience is Paramount

These stocks can remain "cheap" for years. The market can ignore a statistically cheap stock for a very long time, requiring immense patience from the investor.

Diversification is Essential

Graham never advocated for placing a large bet on a single cigar butt. He insisted on owning a diversified basket of at least 20-30 NCAV stocks to play the statistical probabilities. Some will inevitably fail, but the winners are expected to more than compensate for the losers.

---

A Timeless Tool for the Contrarian Investor

Finding true NCAV stocks today, especially in a roaring bull market, is more challenging than in Graham's era. However, they still appear, particularly during market downturns or within overlooked international markets. Using a robust stock screener and performing careful due diligence is key.

For the investor willing to look where others won't, the NCAV formula remains a timeless and powerful guide. It forces a discipline of conservatism and provides a tangible, asset-backed basis for an investment decision. While the market chases fleeting narratives, the NCAV investor focuses on a simple, powerful truth: the value held on the balance sheet. And in the long run, that truth often pays handsome dividends.